Page 1 of 1

Blacjack - Sap - Kosh

PostPosted: Sat May 11, 2019 7:38 pm
by Whitechapel Jack
I have a question about what other keepers think about the Blackjack in 7e. As a weapon it does 1d8 + db thats like a spear, heavy club or longsword...... A sap is 6" long made of leather or canvas with some lead bird shot in the end to give it some weight.... In 6e the sap had a special rule that the damage you rolled was compared to your hp and rolled on the resistance table to see if you were knocked out and without the book in front of me I think the target only took 1 hp of real damage but in 7e a ko is a maneuver (if you succeed the target takes 1 hp and is out cold, pg 125 of keepers book)
Without the special rule I feel the damage is to high, the weapon just isn't big or heavy enough to justify it. I think it was basically copy and pasted without changes because really no other weapons were changed that I see and they just didn't think of this.
I have thought about it a good bit and rejected a few ideas as pointlessly complex and since the ko is a maneuver unnecessary. In the end I have thought the best solution was to just reduce the damage to 1d3+1 like brass knuckles or 1d4 like a small knife. Someone suggested a bonus die on the maneuver to ko someone because that's what its made to do, not sure about that.
Anyway I would love to receive some input

Thanks A Bunch
Keeper Drew